Sapienza Pastry Menu (Update 2025)
Located in Elmont, NY, Sapienza Pastry is a bakery that offers a wide array of delectable treats for every sweet tooth. From decadent cakes like Red Velvet and Oreo Cheesecake to classic pastries like Cannoli and Napoleons, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Customers rave about the freshness and quality of the desserts, with standout items like the Rainbow Cookies and Cannolis being must-tries. Despite some mixed reviews on customer service, the overall consensus is that the baked goods are top-notch and worth a visit. Whether you're looking for a special occasion cake or just a sweet treat to indulge in, Sapienza Pastry has you covered with their delicious offerings. Give them a try and satisfy your cravings for scrumptious desserts!
Cakes
Strawberry Shortcake
Eight to ten slices.
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Eight to ten slices.
Cheesecake
Eight to ten slices.
Marble Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Mixed fruit cheesecake
Plain cheesecake with mixed fruit on top, covered with a glaze serves eight to ten slices.
Rainbow cookie cheesecake
Plain cheesecake with rainbow cookies inside serves eight to ten slices
Chocolate with vanilla buttercream cake
Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream inside and outside serves eight to ten slices
Vanilla with chocolate buttercream cake
Vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream inside and outside serves eight to ten slices
Cannoli cake
Vanilla cake with cannoli cream filling, whip cream on the outside and cannolis on top serves ten to twelve slices
Coconut buttercream cake
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and coconut flakes serves eight to ten slices
Red velvet cake
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting serves eight to ten
Carrot cake
Carrot cake with cream cheese frosting serves eight to ten
Oreo cake
Chocolate cake with cookies and cream buttercream serves eight to ten slices
Vanilla buttercream cake
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream on the inside and outside serves eight to ten slices
Chocolate buttercream cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream on the inside and outside serves eight to ten slices
Lemon buttercream cake
Vanilla cake with lemon filling, vanilla buttercream on outside serves eight to ten
Mocha buttercream cake
Chocolate cake with mocha buttercream on the outside and inside serves eight to ten slices
Pineapple and Strawberry buttercream cake
Vanilla cake with pineapple and strawberry filling with vanilla buttercream on the outside serves eight to ten slices
Half and half vanilla buttercream cake
Layer of chocolate cake with a layer of vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream on the inside and outside serves eight to ten slices
Half and half chocolate buttercream cake
Layer of chocolate cake with a layer of vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream on the inside and outside serves eight to ten slices
Oreo Cheesecake
Oreo cheesecake is a creamy dessert filled with rich cheesecake and mixed Oreo pieces.
Fill Your Own Canoli Kit
One lb. cannoli cream and 20 shells.
Cannoli, Large
The classic Italian favorite - a crunchy shell filled with delicious world famous cannoli cream and topped with green-colored coconut flakes
Napoleon, Large
Filled with our rich homemade custard and cannoli cream sandwiched between flaky layers of delicate puff dough and topped off with fondant icing
Eclair with vanilla custard
Vanilla Custard filling with a delicious chocolate covering.. the classic eclair.
Old Fashion Napoleon
Vanilla cake soaked in a bakers rum filled with our rich vanilla and chocolate custard topped with a flaky pastry top with powdered sugar on top
Chocolate mouse cake slice
Our chocolate cake filled with our famous chocolate mouse cream topped with a layer of whip cream and cocoa powder on top
Red velvet cake slice
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting cake slice.
Carrot cake slice
Carrot cake with cream cheese frosting cake slice
Lobster tail
Flaky pastry stuffed with our famous french cream filling and top with powdered sugar on top
Eclair with chocolate custard
Chocolate custard filling with a delicious chocolate covering.. the classic eclair
Strawberry mouse cake slice
Vanilla cake with our delicious strawberry mousse topped with a layer of whip cream and a strawberry drizzle on top
Sfogliatella
Flaky pastry with bakers cheese
Brownie
A yummy brownie is a sweet, chocolatey treat with a soft inside and a slightly crispy top. Its perfect for chocolate lovers!
Cannoli Saint Joseph
A crispy pastry shell filled with sweet, creamy ricotta and often topped with powdered sugar or decorations.
Vanilla Custard Saint Joseph
A soft pastry filled with smooth, creamy vanilla custard and topped with powdered sugar or a cherry for a touch of sweetness.
French Eclair
A light, airy pastry filled with whipped cream and French cream, often topped with a dusting of powdered sugar for a delicate sweetness.
Pastry
Cookies
1 lb. Rainbow Cookies
1 Lb of assorted sandwich cookies
An assorted box of our different famous sandwich butter cookies filled with raspberry jelly
1 Lb of mixed cookies
An assorted box of our famous butter cookies
M&M cookie Large
Large cookie with M&M chocolate candies.
Chocolate chip cookie Large
Large cookie with chocolate chips inside.
Linzer Tart
Chocolate cupcake with oreo
Chocolate cupcake with cookies and cream buttercream
Vanilla cupcake with vanilla
Vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream
Carrot cake cupcake
Carrot cake cupcake with cream cheese frosting
Vanilla Cupcake
Vanilla Cake with vanilla hard icing
Vanilla cupcake with icing
Vanilla cupcake with chocolate hard icing
Red velvet cupcake with buttercream
Red velvet cupcake with vanilla buttercream
Vanilla cup with chocolate
Vanilla cupcake with chocolate buttercream
Vanilla cupcake with oreo
Vanilla cupcake with cookies and cream buttercream
Vanilla cupcake with strawberry
Vanilla cupcake with strawberry buttercream
Vanilla cupcake with strawberry buttercream
Red velvet cupcake with cream cheese frosting
Chocolate cupcake with chocolate icing
Chocolate cupcake with chocolate hard icing
Chocolate cupcake with strawberry
Chocolate cupcake with strawberry buttercream
Chocolate cupcake with vanilla
Chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream
Chocolate cupcake with vanilla icing
Chocolate cupcake with vanilla hard icing
Cupcakes
Biscotti
Chocolate Fancy Nut-1 Ib
A chocolate biscotti cookie loaded with nuts
Regina (Sesame Seed Cookie)
A tasty traditional favorite covered with sesame see.
Anisette - 1 Lb
A well known favorite, delicately flavored with anise and toasted to perfection
Anisette coconut - 1Lb
A well known favorite, delicately flavored with anise and coconut toasted to perfection
Vanilla fancy nut - 1Lb
A vanilla biscotti cookie loaded with nuts.
Anisette chocolate chip - 1Lb
A well known favorite, delicately flavored with anise and chocolate chips inside, toasted to perfection
Anisette fruit and nut - 1Lb
A well known favorite, delicately flavored with anise, fruit and nut, toasted to perfection.
Chocolate Mousse Cup
Our delectable chocolate mousse mixed with homemade fudge and topped with whipped cream and a cherry... its ice cream without the ice
Strawberry Mousse Cup
Our amazing strawberry mousse.. In a cup
Tiramisu Cup
Our famous tiramisu in a cup, vanilla cake soaked in a bakers rums filled with our delicious tiramisu filling
Pastry cups
Pies
Apple Crumb Pie
Delicious apple pie with a cinnamon crumb topping.
Apple pie
Apple pie with a lattice pattern crust.